Thoughts about 偽悪病患者 by Udaru Oshita, with spoilers.
I finished 偽悪病患者 by Udaru Oshita, the first short story of the Sogensha collection with the same name. It is epistolary short story with a really good murder case and a lot of ingenuity.
Not only is the murder solved remotely by someone who is not present on the scene, but the only source the brother has to solve it are Kyoko’s letters, which conceal a lot and misrepresent the truth. It is very clever, especially because both sides are very good at deception. Not only did the brother see through his sister’s deceit, but the deception she uses is really well done. The brother’s warning and the title of the short story make us think that Saji is the problem, and the reader is bound to jump to conclusion and fall for Kyoko’s cunning. You could say that in the same way that Kyoko misleads her brother so does the author, misleading the reader with a focus on Saji at the beginning of the story.
And it’s easy to fall for it, because Saji is a really interesting character. A 偽悪病患者 who devises ways to commit petty crimes, but never actually puts them into action. He said that he was preparing a crime, something that would be his big oeuvre, and he compares it to the ultimate work of an artist.
僕は、前人未到の境地に分け入って、悪の最高峰をきわめようというのだ。
But in the end, as the brother says, 佐治は、矢張り、偽悪病患者でしかなかった。
The short story is not long, but there is so much going on in it. It is also engrossing and a really good murder mystery.