Thought on the first story in 测谎师 by 刘一.
I am not a big reader of true crime, and I bought this book mainly because it was one of the rare crime-related titles in the bookshop I went to. Most books were Chinese translations of Korean novels or romance and classic literary fiction.
The idea of a specialist who’s here to analyse (with a lie detector and their own expertise) whether a suspect is lying or not makes me very uncomfortable. The idea that those results could be used against you in court, or at least could influence the police investigation, just because you had an unfortunate physiological response at the wrong moment is downright scary. People can be triggered by a multitude of things, and it’s specific to everyone’s own personality, past and trauma. It can’t be analysed by a psychologist who just met the person in question.
This whole branch of criminology feels more like yet another tool to pin crimes to convenient victims.
Anyway, this was my state of mind when starting the book, and the first story only reinforced my disgust towards this practice, despite the author’s efforts to popularise it.
For example, she asked the suspect to pick between four choices at the beginning of the interview:
A.执业律师,B.甜美萝莉,C.中年女性,D.高中同学
And then she explains that A represents the law, B girlfriend, C mother and D friend. She then concludes that the suspect has a girlfriend because he chose B, even though he tried to deny the existence of the girlfriend at first.
But like, seriously?? Is this real? Sounds like a cheap personality test in a magazine. The rest of the interview with the suspect did not convince me of anything, so I remain a strong opponent of the practice.
However, the case was interesting, and I think I’ll enjoy the book, not for the work made by the criminal psychologist, but for the stories it tells, and how people find themselves involved in murder cases.