Inhae @blog

Inhae @blog@social.inhae.blog · 10:48

I really liked 彼が殺したか by Shiro Hamao (浜尾四郎). The solution was interesting, but I mostly loved the first part of the story where we try to understand the state of mind of the suspect and think about possible scenarios of what really happened.

What I loved the most is how Shiro Hamao uses his position as a lawyer in his story. First, he underlines that he is not a writer of mystery novels, and that he will talk about the case from his point of view as a lawyer, which gives the impression that the case is a real one.

Then he often addresses writers of crime fiction, for example to say that a device or trick popular in detective fiction is or is not also common in real cases.

This short story also contains reflexions that are not often taken into account in other mystery novels of the time. For example, how the interpretation of the case could affect whether the suspect would have a chance to escape the death penalty or not.