Inhae @blog

Inhae @blog@social.inhae.blog · 17:21

I finished 首切り島の一夜 by Shogo Utano, and I can’t say I disliked it because it was well written, and as I said, each chapter was a very interesting story, but I’m of kind of feeling angry about it too.

First, even though the chapters were interesting separately, I felt tired at some point to get to know a character, and then their story is just over, and we jump to the next one.

Most importantly, I feel betrayed by the book, and it pisses me off. The book would be exactly the same without the murder story. Just a collection of related short stories: a group of people go for a school trip 40 years later. Then each chapter is the story of one of these people. Give it another title, another cover and another summary. I would not have bought this book, and I would have read something else instead.

The fact that it starts with a murder and the group can’t leave the island because of bad weather suggests a very coded, very classic type of mystery novel. BUT the murder brings nothing to the novel, it could as well not happen. So it looks to me like an unfair trick to grab the reader’s attention and appeal to a certain type of readership. And yes you can say that the author is just shaking the norms or playing with the reader’s expectations, but first it’s genre fiction, not literary fiction, you can break rules but not get rid of what makes it of a certain genre entirely, and second, there’s so many books that I want to read, I don’t want to spend a whole week of reading time just to enjoy the experience of having my expectations broken lol.

And sure I could have DNF it, but the novel is very good at making you believe that all these stories will matter in the end, that clues for a motive lie somewhere, or at least, that the author is using a very clever narrative trick that would be reveal at the end.