Now 10% into 網內人 by Chan Ho-kei, and I love the story. Overall, I like how it is written, everything is very detailed, there’s a constant exploration of how characters are feeling, no loose end, and everything is described in details.
However, I just read through a scene that kind of broke the realism of the story until now. It’s a bit of the “super-hero detective” kind of scene, and that’s a motif that I really dislike, just because it’s done over and over again. I think that’s why I prefer police procedural over private detective when it comes to detective fiction. Private detectives often have to be eccentric, they’re geniuses, and they’re a step ahead, like they planned everything, exactly what was described in the scene in question. I find these things annoying. On the contrary, police detectives often relies on procedures, sometimes make mistakes, they’re more or less always a step behind which creates a sense of danger and suspense. (of course some police detectives are written like private detective, so the distinction should be more solo/genius detective ≠ procedural).
I also think that the novel tends to over explain things sometimes, even though these things should be obvious for the reader. I hope it won’t go too much in this direction. I much prefer when the author trusts the reader to understand situations and implications by themselves, rather than explain everything.
And another thing is our protagonist. I find her a bit dull and uninteresting. I was not impressed by how hard she’s working, never complaining, sacrificing herself for her sister and keeping the family afloat despite all the negative things that happened to them. It was a bit exaggerated, and while the intend was certainly to draw a positive portrait of Nga-Yee, to me she felt a bit too perfect and deprived of emotions. But more than anything, she is very slow to understand things, which I find very irritating. I think it is made on purpose so that the author can explain things to the reader (through other characters explaining things to her), especially things related to computer science, as this is the major topic of the novel. I hope though that it won’t be too focused on internet and hacking methods, and more on the characters, especially the personality and secrets (?) of the younger sister.
So for now, I enjoy the story and I really want to know the truth, but I don’t like any of the two main protagonists: the elder sister because I find her irritatingly slow, and the hacker because he falls in the category of the genius detective.